Last Saturday marked the opening of the New Bedford Symphony
Orchestra's 91st season and conductor Philip Rice's fourth
season as music director. For this concert, Mr. Rice designed
a program that showcased the considerable talents of two
of the orchestra's principal players, and challenged the
entire orchestra to tackle a work whose performance would
have been inconceivable here three years ago: Gustav Mahler's
Symphony No. Five in C-sharp Minor, first performed in
Cologne, Germany, in 1904.
In his three years as music director, Mr. Rice has transformed
the NBSO into one of the top regional orchestras in the
country. Typical of the fine young musicians who make
up the orchestra are principal harpist Sarah Manning and
principal flutist Timothy Macri, two accomplished performers
whose technical agility and musical intelligence made
up for the thin texture and repetitiveness of Mozart's
youthful "French" Concerto in C Major for Flute
and Harp.
Happy to yield to this irrepressibly sweet and cheerful
piece, they dazzled the audience with their enchanting
duets and energetic solos. The robust Mr. Macri appeared
to be playfully courting Ms. Manning, who with nimble
fingers parried his seductive solos with equally seductive
solos for the harp. Both played their cadenzas brilliantly,
but it was Mr. Macri's charmingly flirtatious imitation
of a songbird that finally won Ms. Manning's heart.
Let us hope Mr. Macri, who has been holding master classes
in New Bedford's public schools, will be equally successful
at wooing young people to love classical music, perhaps
repairing some of the damage caused by the savage cuts
to the city's art education budget.
Mozart's delightful piece was the perfect foil to the
gargantuan Mahler symphony the orchestra performed after
intermission. Under Mr. Rice's masterful captaincy, this
"titanic" (his phrase) vessel not only stayed
afloat, but for every plunge into the depths of Mahler's
oceanic "nostalgia for the absolute" (George
Steiner's phrase), this magnificent symphony broke through
the surface with the audacious energy of a breaching whale
soaring toward the sky.
Gustav Mahler believed, "The symphony must be like
a world that contains everything at its disposal."
Written after personal tragedies and severe hemorrhaging
nearly killed him, his fifth symphony begins with a wake-up
call from a single unaccompanied trumpet, followed by
a massive assault by the brass and percussion that introduces
a lugubrious funeral march followed by the Sturm und Drang
of wildly conflicting themes. According to Maestro Rice,
this symphony contains 214 tempo changes, not counting
rallentandi and rubati the conductor may supply.
Throughout the performance of this difficult work, the
orchestra displayed phenomenal discipline and restraint.
Their musicianship and Mr. Rice's subtle control enabled
them to skillfully respond to Mahler's often shockingly
abrupt changes of tempo, so that the most treacherous
transitions went smoothly.
One of the most stunning instances of the firm but delicate
control Maestro Rice and the orchestra are capable of
achieving together came at the very end of the turbulent
first movement, where Mahler scored a rest followed by
a single note marked SF, for sforzando (forcefully).This
note, which resolves the tempestuous battle between death
and fear on the one hand, and the soul's hopeful yearning
for natural innocence and blissful joy on the other, is
most often played as a sharp, angry jab, or jolt.
A few conductors have read the score differently, however,
and Philip Rice is one of them. The NBSO played this mysterious
note as an emphatic but ethereal burst of sound that seemed
to create the possibility of a silence so profound that
it could only exist in a spiritual realm.
The haunting Adagietto was allegedly written as a love
letter to Alma Schindler, Mahler's future wife, but over
the years, this achingly beautiful, slow movement has
come to seem more like an elegy for the world (or imagined
world) of faith, civility and order destroyed by the Franco-Prussian
war that foreshadowed the violence of the 20th century.
Although some conductors have played this movement faster,
Mr. Rice drew from its plangent melody silent tears.
At the end of the symphony, this theme reappears in a
joyous transformation that reaffirms the composer's embrace
of life. Along with allusions to symphonies of Beethoven
and Brahms and German Ländler, dance hall music and
Viennese waltzes, this great work concludes with a rondo-finale
that is operatic in its lushly lyrical intensity.
After the concert, looking pale as a ghost from the physical
and emotional demands of conducting this explosive work,
Maestro Rice told reception guests he had only had time
for four rehearsals with the orchestra -- a fact that
makes this performance an even more extraordinary feat
than I had imagined.
Mahler's Fifth Symphony makes enormous demands on the
conductor and the instrumentalists. To a man and woman,
the brasses played their frequent solos with consummate
artistry, especially the velvety trombones. For the strings,
Mahler composed music so frenzied that at times Concertmaster
Jesse Holstein and his violin section appeared to be trying
to saw their instruments into tiny pieces, so vehement
was their bowing in certain passages; yet, the overall
effect was beautiful.
Several people commented that they were glad not to be
subjected to the speeches and exhortations that so annoyed
supporters of the symphony before last season's opening
night concert. The only pre-performance comment was a
necessary one from Mr. Rice, informing the audience that
the orchestra would not perform Samuel Barber's School
for Scandal Overture because it would make the concert
excessively long.
Although that was definitely a wise move, a friend said
he actually found himself wishing the 75-minute-long Mahler
had lasted longer.
That's an achievement of which the New Bedford Symphony
can be proud.
This story appeared on Page B3
of The Standard-Times on October 5, 2005.
|